


CATALYSTS
Mapping the scale and influence of global science philanthropy

INFLECTION
Rethinking research funding and evaluation in the agentic AI era

EFFORT
Estimating Funding Friction: Outcomes, Resource cost and Time

Undisciplined
Future models of funding and evaluating transdisciplinary research [completed]

Portfolios
Research funding landscape analysis [completed]

Peer Review
RoRI Atlas of Peer Review [completed]

PATHWAYS
Advancing Research on Research Use to Enhance Positive Impact

Narratives
The uses and evaluation of researchers’ narrative CVs

MetaROR
Translating Publish-Review-Curate outputs into actionable signals for research funders: A MetaROR Study


Matthew
A study of cumulative advantages in funding allocation [completed]
CATALYSTS
Mapping the scale and influence of global science philanthropy
Summary
The cocktail of public, private, and philanthropic money sustaining the world’s research systems is being shaken like never before. The post-1945 settlement that underpinned public funding of basic research is being contested, the geopolitical map of funding is being redrawn, and a fresh wave of AI-linked wealth is entering philanthropy.
Foundations bring distinctive competencies to research systems—patience, agility, and a willingness to back people and ideas public funders will not. Yet, philanthropy remains the least well-measured component of global research. As governments lean on foundations to fill budget gaps, private money steers research agendas, and new non-profit models opt out of traditional publishing, understanding this shifting ecosystem becomes critical.
CATALYSTS establishes “the philanthropic layer” as a standing object of metascientific attention. By building an open, multi-layer, AI-enabled map of who funds what, the project examines where philanthropy complements, catalyses, or substitutes for public spending worldwide.
RoRI Project team

Senior Research Fellow, RoRI/UCL

Research Fellow, RoRI/UCL

Head of Programmes, RoRI

Executive Director, RoRI/UCL
Laura Ryan
Science Works
Ben Johnson
Science Works
Will Stone
Science Works

RoRI/University of Sheffield

RoRI/CWTS

RoRI/CWTS
CSTI, University of Cambridge

Imperial College London
Partner organisations
The project in detail
Without a better understanding of the philanthropic dimensions of global science, we miss some of the most dynamic forces, drivers, and institutions shaping research today. Five factors make this work urgent:
- Scale and leverage: Philanthropy now represents a fifth of the research base of US universities and rivals the NSF in grant volume, while a fresh wave of AI-linked fortunes could add tens of billions of dollars annually.
- Substitution risk: As public budgets tighten, governments may lean on foundations to fill funding gaps. Clarifying where philanthropy complements, catalyses, or risks legitimising public retreat is a central strategic question for funders worldwide.
- Institutional innovation: Philanthropy has become the proving ground for novel organisational models—including Focused Research Organisations (FROs), thesis-driven funds, and non-publishing labs—whose lessons public funders are increasingly seeking to adopt.
- Direction and legitimacy: Concentrated private wealth steering research priorities raises critical questions around accountability, plutocratic influence, and the protection of open civic space.
- Data as infrastructure: Philanthropies increasingly step in to preserve withdrawn public datasets and build the open digital commons that AI-driven discovery depends on. A field that funds data infrastructure for others urgently needs better data infrastructure about itself.
Mapping science philanthropy presents hard metascientific challenges: fragmented regulatory filings, inconsistent cross-border definitions, and an expanding body of discovery that deliberately bypasses journal bibliometrics.
CATALYSTS tackles these gaps through an integrated mixed-methods programme:
- Landscape Data Infrastructure: Curating a global register of 600–1,000 foundations and developing output-agnostic tracing across code, data, preprints, and policy citations alongside traditional scholarly literature.
- Multi-layer network analysis & AI maps: Building coupled network layers (funders, grants, recipients, outputs, patents, and datasets) to reveal structural clusters, division of labour, and funding influence pathways.
- Institutional case studies & interviews: Documenting 12 emerging institutional models (including FROs, AI-lab foundations, and public–philanthropic hybrids) alongside 40–50 in-depth leadership interviews across North America, Europe, Asia, Africa, and Latin America.
- Foresight & Delphi scenarios: Running an expert Argumentative Delphi panel to model vectors of continuity, disruption, and uncertainty, creating five-year strategic scenarios to 2031.
Project timeline
CATALYSTS runs for 13 months, from October 2026 to November 2027, launching formally at the RoRI Consortium Meeting in Barcelona and concluding with a flagship report launch event at Wellcome in London in late 2027.
Outputs
- Live, AI-enabled Landscape Maps: An interactive, openly licensed web resource mapping funders, topics, instruments, and pathways across time.
- Flagship report: A comprehensive 60–80 page policy report synthesizing global trends, measurement challenges, 12 institutional cases, and 2031 strategic scenarios.
- Living Evidence Map & Taxonomy: An open, updatable literature review and classification system for philanthropic actors and funding vehicles.
- Tailored Strategy briefings & Policy briefs: Decision-maker briefs on public–philanthropic additionality, co-funding frameworks, and portfolio positioning.
- Academic papers: Peer-reviewed studies on multi-source funding measurement, network structures of global philanthropy, and emerging institutional models.

